top of page



Life is unpredictable. And with all its twists and turns and ups and downs, it is easy to become anxious and worried because of all the “what ifs” swirling around in your mind. When it comes to rental property disasters, stress is unavoidable. But it is manageable. Trust us, we’ve seen it all.

It’s reported that over half of all homes in the U.S. are located in areas prone to tornadoes, earthquakes or hurricanes. It’s best to be informed on how to handle these kinds of issues should they ever arise. Better safe than sorry.

Here are nine common rental property disasters and comprehensive advice on how to deal with each.

Disclaimer: Laws and ordinances affecting rental property vary greatly, so be sure to check your local legislation.

Scenario #1 – Severe Weather Damage to the Property

A severe thunder and wind storm has caused a tree branch to fall on your rental property, breaking part of the roof and windows. What do you do?

  1. When it is safe, take photos/videos to document the damage before you perform any repairs.

  2. Make the necessary temporary fixes to prevent further damage to your property, such as covering broken windows, leaky roofs and damaged walls. Do not do any permanent repairs until your insurance company has inspected the property, and you have reached an agreement on the cost of repairs.

  3. Save all receipts, including those you collected from performing the temporary repairs. Plastic tarps or sheeting used to protect broken windows and damaged buildings from additional exposure to elements might be covered, depending on your insurance policy.

  4. Tenants are not responsible for paying rent during the time the property is uninhabitable. Depending on the terms of your lease, you may need to provide them with temporary shelter. Some insurance policies may help you cover the cost.

  5. When doing repairs, use the most practical, cost-effective and preventative (reinforced, stronger glass, etc.) materials to avoid any further damage in the future. Notable home contractor Mike Holmes makes the point that, “… we can’t stop the weather, but we can be smart and think ahead to avoid damage caused by snow and rain before it starts.“

  6. Become informed on your insurer’s procedures and be prepared to file an insurance claim. This Huffington Post article has a great list of tips on how to file a home insurance report.

Scenario #2 – Pipe Burst/Flooding

A pipe in your rental property basement has burst, and the basement apartment has completely flooded. What do you do?

  1. Document the damage by taking photos or videos.

  2. Check to see if your insurance policy includes flooding of any kind. Don’t just take it from us. Bob Vila makes a strong case for flood insurance.

  3. Have a professional assess the damage and estimate the total cost for repairs. This article from This Old House is a great case study on what to expect as far as process and costs are concerned.

  4. If sanitation is required, or if you aren’t knowledgeable or proficient in plumbing, call a professional to ensure safety requirements are met.

  5. Check your lease agreement to see if you are responsible for any of the damages to the personal property of your tenants. Rarely is the owner responsible for the damage, but it’s best to double-check so there are no surprises.

  6. Save all receipts for possible reimbursements and personal filings for tax purposes.

Scenario #3 – Pest or Insect Infestation

A tenant has reported a severe cockroach infestation. What do you do?

Most leases state that the tenant is responsible for all pest control unless it was a pre-existing issue. If you’re able to prove the tenant caused the infestation, you can usually charge the costs to the tenant.

Take a close look at your local laws. If your property is a single family home, you can specify on the lease that tenants are responsible for costs related to pest control. In many states, if you own a multi-family property, the owner is responsible, no matter what.

Even if you have clear expectations in the lease about pest control, your tenant may expect you to deal with the issue. Here’s what you can do.

  1. Call a professional exterminator or pest control service. Roaches often survive DIY elimination efforts. The Bug Lady – aka Missy Henriksen, the Vice President of Public Affairs for the National Pest Management Association has identified 5 Signs For When to call in a Pro and states that “… there are a lot of DIY steps you can take to help prevent pests from finding their way into your home, but even these are most effective when completed in partnership with a pest professional. And, if you suspect you have an infestation, your first step should always be to call a licensed and trained pest professional.”

  2. Follow their instructions carefully for what to do with the personal items and furniture in the rental unit.

  3. Schedule a time for them to deal with the issue.

  4. Implement preventative measures to avoid a recurring issue (like better-sealed windows, keeping counters clear of food, and frequently taking out the garbage). Since roaches and other pests, can easily enter your home via a grocery store bag, box, unsealed walls/doors/windows, and other non-solid items, it can be tough to avoid.

Scenario #4 – Criminal Activity by Tenants

You are suspicious that criminal activity (like drug dealing) is taking place in your rental property. What do you do?

Preventative tip: Reduce the likelihood of being held responsible for the criminal acts of your tenants by performing a thorough screening of your applicants. Be SURE to require the tenants to sign a crime free addendum as part of your lease.

  1. Don’t accept cash payments for rent if you suspect criminal activity.

  2. Remind yourself of the provisions in your lease referring to criminal activity and find out what, if anything, it says about criminal activity conducted on the property.

  3. Consult a security expert and real estate attorney to help you answer any questions concerning actions that you can take.

  4. Evict anyone who violates these provisions immediately.

  5. If you receive any complaints from neighbors about drug dealing or other criminal

  6. activity, respond immediately. Consult the police if necessary.

Scenario #5 – Tenant Goes MIA/Does Not Pay Rent

Your tenant has pulled a Houdini and disappeared without paying their rent. What do you do?

  1. Try your best to reach them through the contact information you have. Contact their friends or relatives, as well.

  2. Refer to your local laws on what actions you can take if someone has moved out and owes you money.

  3. You may need to issue a summons to take that person to court, so be prepared for a lengthy process in order to be reimbursed.

  4. If your lease states that you can evict the tenant after a period of time after rent has not been paid, fill out the appropriate documents to make it official. You’ll want everything to be clear, so you can rent your property out again ASAP. The tenants must have access to the property until the eviction is complete. You cannot change locks until this time.

  5. If their personal belongings have been left behind, you may have to store them for 60 days (either on or off site) before they can be sold or discarded. Note that you must notify the tenant before doing anything with their belongings. Before you do anything thought, look into your state laws. Another consideration, while storage costs could be considered the tenant’s responsibility, it could be difficult to make

  6. them pay.

Scenario #6 – Eviction Is the Only Option (Last Straw)

You have tried every attempt to get your tenant to stop violating a term in their lease, but they have taken no action or initiative to do so. What do you do?

  1. Take a close look at the terms of your lease before you serve an eviction notice to your tenant.

  2. Make sure to include the reason for the eviction and the deadline to vacate the premises.

  3. Also state the consequences of not vacating the premises in time (escalation to legal action, etc.).

  4. Tie up all loose ends and, if possible, make sure the name of your tenant(s) are in an eviction record database to help future rental property owners avoid trouble.

  5. Michele Lerner from REALTOR®.com’s ‘Ask Michele’ blog offers the following advice, “Since the tenants know you want to sell your home, you will probably have to give them an incentive to move out, such as a financial compensation or waiving their last month’s rent.”

Scenario #7 – Rental Prices Drop Dramatically (Marketplace Is Suffering)

You have a tenant who knows that rental prices in your location are dropping due to the marketplace being flooded with supply. They threaten to leave unless you drop your rent price. What do you do?

  1. Assess the market. This article in the New York Times provides comprehensive details on how to do so.

  2. If you are not familiar with assessing markets and competitive pricing, it might be best to consult a real estate agent for expert advice.

  3. You can offer incentives such as new appliances, to entice your tenants to stay. Not only will this help keep the tenant happy, but it will bring your property value up. According to Paula Poskon, an analyst with Robert W. Baird & Co., “Many companies are doing whatever they can to keep units occupied, especially heading into the seasonally slower leasing period.”

  4. Test the marketplace empirically and put your property listing up with a certain price tag to see what kind of interest you can generate. If there is a lot of interest in your property, do not budge with your current tenants and let them know you have a waitlist for the property.

  5. If after doing thorough research and consulting experts, you still think you will need to drop the price, make sure you implement a condition saying you can increase the rent (by giving proper notice) at your discretion. Don’t trap yourself.

Scenario #8 – Your Rental Property Violates Code

Laws, regulations, codes, permits are ever-changing. You find out your property has fallen behind the times, and an inspection is coming up. What do you do?

  1. Find out exactly what you have to do to be up to code. Keep in mind that the landlord is liable for any code violations.

  2. Do what you can yourself and hire the appropriate professionals to handle the rest.

  3. Keep all your receipts. Not only do they help you track all business expenses and are essential for tax purposes, but they can be used as evidence for repairs and maintenance when you meet with the inspector.

  4. Pencil in a code review into your calendar with a reminder, so you never fall behind again.

Scenario #9 – You Reach the End of Your Rope (Need Professional Property Management Help)

Your blood pressure is consistently on the rise, and you aren’t sleeping well at night. Turns out this was a lot more work than you had initially thought. What do you do?

  1. Explore your options. Find out what types of technology and tools might help to alleviate some stress.

  2. Do a cost-benefit analysis and take into account your time and stress.

  3. Take the plunge and hire a pro!


The word “disaster” can be more intimidating than the actual disaster. Make sure to give yourself a break. Remind yourself that these things happen.

Sometimes you just need to take a deep breath and a new perspective to realize you will be okay. And it won’t hurt to study this guide carefully, so you know what steps you can take to return things back to normal.

How to cope with Rental Disaster.

bottom of page